Amanda McClure married her dad Larry McClure, top right, then spent her wedding night dismembering her ex Thomas McGuire, bottom right (Pictures: Facebook/McDowell County Sheriff’s Office)
A daughter had sex with her own father, married him – and then spent their wedding night dismembering her ex-boyfriend. Amanda McClure, 31, and her dad Larry McClure got wed on March 11 2019 – almost a month after they murdered Amanda’s boyfriend Thomas McGuire, 38, in Skygusty, Virginia.
Amanda’s sister Anna Marie Choudhary told her sentencing hearing Wednesday how she had acted as a witness for her father and sister’s wedding and helped cover-up their incestuous wedding. She said: ‘They took me and said I needed to act like a happy witness.’
Explaining what happened next, Choudhary told of how McGuire’s body was exhumed and dismembered ‘that very night they were married.’ Choudhary explained that Larry McClure wanted to sell his house, and decided to rebury McGuire’s remains in two separate places to minimize the chances of them being found by its new owner.
She said the McClures ‘went on like nothing had happened’ after beating and drugging McGuire to death and ‘started having a relationship as soon as he was buried.’
Details of the McClures’ incestuous wedding emerged as Anne Marie Choudhury, pictured, admitting helping her sister and father carry out the murder (Picture: McDowell County Sheriff’s Office)
Choudhary faces up to 40 years jail after striking a plea deal which saw her admit second-degree murder.
Larry McClure was jailed for life without parole last August, with Amanda McClure jailed for 40 years in October 2020, the Bluefield Daily Telegraph reported.
During Wednesday’s plea hearing, Choudhary, a nurse, offered stomach-churning detail of how Larry McClure had sledgehammered bed rails into McGuire’s corpse two weeks after his murder to ensure he was dead.
McGuire traveled from Minnesota with Amanda McClure to visit her relatives, and was killed during what his girlfriend claimed was a Valentine’s Day ‘trust game’ she wanted to play.
Amanda McClure, pictured, admitted killing her ex at an earlier court hearing, and was sentenced to 40 years behind bars (Picture: McDowell County Sheriff’s Office)
He was tied up, hit over the head with a wine bottle, injected with crystal meth and ultimately strangled by Choudhary during a three day torture session.
Amanda McClure was put up for adoption as a child, but began a sexual relationship with her dad – a convicted pedophile – after getting back in touch with him as an adult.
Both father and daughter were addicted to crystal meth at the time of the murder.
She is said to have turned on McGuire after learning that her boyfriend had also previously dated Choudhary.
The horrific murder came to light after Larry McClure was arrested in September 2019 for failing to register as a sex offender.
He subsequently confessed to McGuire’s murder, with the dead man’s body found and exhumed by investigators shortly afterwards.
Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at [email protected]
For more stories like this, check our news page